The Outback Steakhouse Putsch 2010

I thought this was an interesting article about the rise of “patriot” groups in America and wanted to add my two cents.

http://motherjones.com/politics/2010/03/oath-keepers

The thing that struck me, both about the piece and the groups profiled therein was the disconnect in how these people saw themselves and what they were doing and how they were viewed by those on the outside.

Stewart Rhodes, a Constitutional lawyer, for instance:

(He) had been fascinated by the notion that if German soldiers and police had refused to follow orders, Hitler could have been stopped.

Hitler and Nazis seem to be a central theme with these groups. President Obama and big government are likened to the German National Socialists a few times in this piece.

Immediately, this seems off, as the Nazis are, contrary to any connotations you might get from a name which includes the world “socialist”, a far-right group who would be at odd with many of the liberal policies of the Obama administration, let alone with the idea of a black man running the country.

But “left” or “right”, those are just ideas and the list of crimes committed in the name of each is long. But  beyond simple political affiliation, there’s a deeper truth.

The people in these groups tend to see themselves as modern-day George Washingtons, the only men brave enough to stand up to a tyrannical power and do what is right.

But, I see them much differently. I do, in fact, see them as something Hitler was. Not the Hitler of 1939 who invaded Poland, but the Hitler of 1923’s Beer Hall Putsch.

The Beer Hall Putsch involved a group of angry veterans who felt that their country was being betrayed by illegitimate leaders who didn’t have the best interests of their homeland in mind. They too, felt the “system” was broken and needed to be “fixed” by a violent uprising.

It was a spectacular failure and in the immediate aftermath, its purveyors were looked at as bumbling buffoons. Many of the comments I’ve read from people on this present-day story center around the theme of “these are just ignorant rednecks who can’t make a difference and will just end up blowing themselves up”.

Again, all of this should seem really familiar.

Knowing what we know now, history has shown what a huge mistake it can be to underestimate people like this. People whose currency is the anger of the disenfranchised.

What these angry people don’t realize is that while sometimes you do have to stand up to the government, more often than not, you have to stand up to the people who would want to stand up to the government. And not just them, but anyone who would court their votes or their viewership or their political cachet.

There’s a system of government in place in our country that is over two hundred years old. Maybe you don’t think it’s working anymore. By all means, you should feel free to voice this opinion. But just because you feel like not enough people are listening to your opinion and agreeing with you, it doesn’t mean that you have the right to push those opinions onto other people with the threat of violence.

And that’s what this is really about, all high-minded rationalizations about Constitutional Law, aside. This isn’t a promise to uphold the Constitution at all costs, this is a threat to ignore the political will of the majority of Americans and impose your own beliefs upon them. Plain and simple.

Advertisements

9 comments

  1. OK random person, if you say I’m out of my league, I must be. Thanks for your important contribution to the dialog. I guess you just chose to ignore this: “But “left” or “right”, those are just ideas and the list of crimes committed in the name of each is long.”

  2. I agree with most of your points, Eric. Therefore, I feel you are only partially a Nazi. The parts I agreed with were very beautiful and patriotic. The rest was neocon sociofascist leftist pro-choice capitalistic hate speech. Don’t act like you don’t know what I’m talking about. That’s what the Nazis did.

  3. The formidable and au courant Christian comedienne Victoria Jackson debuted a little ukelele ditty titled “There’s a Communist Living in the White House!” at an Altadena tea party recently. It’s on youtube. I was listening to the lyrics. They include claims that Obama’s grandfather and both parents were socialists, and that someone he appointed used a phrase associated with Karl Marx. Clear evidence – to the teabaggers – that the President hates America.

    Wait. No. Please forgive me for the unintentional slur, teabaggers who follow Eric. I meant tea PARTYERS. Totally different demographic.

    My point being that people actually believe this crap.

    What happened to discernment, to analysis, to the freakin’ FACTS? And if all these people can get on the President is guilt-by-association, I think the rest of us can rest easy that we voted correctly.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s